|
|
|
|
|
|
| Research on Methane Detection Error Caused by Lorentzian Profile Approximation |
| LIANG Wen-ke, WEI Guang-fen, WANG Ming-hao |
School of Information and Electronic Engineering, Shandong Technology and Business University, Yantai 264005, China
|
|
|
|
|
Abstract The 2ν3 band R3 branch (6 046.95 cm-1) is the most commonly used band in near-infrared methane detection. The three spectral lines of the R3 branch are very close to each other, and the Lorentzian profile of a spectral line is usually used to describe its spectral shape to correct the second harmonic peak error caused by temperature and pressure. However, the error caused by the Lorentzian profile itself has not received enough attention. In this paper, the TDLAS system is simulated and analyzed as follows. The low-frequency sawtooth wave and the high-frequency sine wave are superimposed to modulate the laser. After the detection gas is absorbed, it is then demodulated by digital lock-in amplification and low-pass filtering, and finally, the second harmonic signal normalized by the first harmonic is obtained by the rotating coordinate system method. By comparing the influence of the Lorentzian profile approximation of a single spectral line and the Voigt profile of three spectral lines on the second harmonic, the second harmonic error caused by the Lorentzian profile approximation under the conditions of temperature and pressure changes is analyzed. The result indicates that: （1） When the pressure and temperature change, the peak error of the second harmonic of the Lorentzian profile is smaller than the average minimum value error; （2） The peak value error of the second harmonic caused by the Lorentzian profile approximation increases significantly with the decrease of pressure. When the temperature is 298 K, and the pressure is reduced to 0.2 atm, the peak value error of the second harmonic of methane gas brought by the Lorentzian profile approximation reaches 65.5%; （3） The second harmonic spectral shape is measured by parameters such as peak-to-valley ratio and harmonic width. When the temperature is 298 K, and the pressure is less than 0.8 atm, the peak-valley ratio error is more than 4.5%, and when the pressure is 1 atm, and the temperature is more than 380 K, the peak-to-valley rate error is more than 4.8%. Since the second harmonic spectral shape error is more sensitive to the peak-to-valley rate parameter, for methane gas at 6 046.95 cm-1, the Lorentzian profile is difficult to apply to the calibration-free algorithm; （4） The Lorentzian profile approximation error decreases as the modulation coefficient increases. When the temperature is 298 K and the pressure is 1 atm, the modulation current is greater than 2.2 mA (corresponding to the modulation factor of 1.33), the second harmonic peak error, peak-to-valley rate error and width error are all less than 3.5%. The proposed Lorentzian profile error analysis method has a certain reference significance for studying the methane detection error of TDLAS caused by profile approximation in the environment of temperature and pressure changes. It can also be extended to TDLAS detection of other gas multi-line bands.
|
|
Received: 2022-04-21
Accepted: 2022-07-11
|
|
|
|
[1] Li Chuanliang，Shao Ligang，Meng Huiyan，et al. Optics Express，2018，26（22）：29330.
[2] Du Yanjun，Peng Zhimin，Ding Yanjun. Optics Express，2020，28（3）：3482.
[3] Zhang Zhihao，Li Meng，Guo Jinjia，et al. Sensors，2021，21（5）：1723.
[4] Cui Ruyue，Dong Lei，Wu Hongpeng，et al. Optics Express，2018，26（19）：24318.
[5] Li Shaomin，Sun Liqun. Chinese Optics Letters，2021，19（3）：031201.
[6] Wang Fei，Jia Shuhai，Wang Yonglin，et al. Applied Sciences，2019，9（14）：2816.
[7] Rieker G B，Jeffries J B，Hanson R K. Applied Optics，2009，48（29）：5546.
[8] DING Wu-wen, SUN Li-qun, YI Lu-ying（丁武文, 孙利群, 衣路英）. Acta Physica Sinica（物理学报），2017，66（10）：100702.
[9] Li Bin，Zheng Chuantao，Liu Huifang，et al. Sensors and Actuators B：Chemical，2016，225：188.
[10] Iseki T. Environmental Geology，2004，46：1064.
[11] ZHOU Yan-wen，MIAO Shu-zhuo，YAO Dan，et al（周言文, 苗澍茁, 姚 丹, 等）. Chinese Journal of Lasers（中国激光），2020，47(6)：0611001.
[12] ZHANG Zhi-rong，WU Bian，XIA Hua，et al（张志荣，吴 边，夏 滑，等）. Acta Physica Sinica（物理学报），2013，62（23）：234204.
[13] ZHANG Zeng-fu, ZOU De-bao, CHEN Wen-liang（张增福，邹得宝，陈文亮）. Opto-Electronic Engineering（光电工程），2014，41（6）：32.
[14] MA Li，FAN Xin-li，ZHANG Shuo，et al（马 砺，范新丽，张 朔，等）. Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis（光谱学与光谱分析），2021，41（11）：3632.
[15] Gordon I E，Rothman L S，Hargreaves R J，et al. Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy & Radiative Transfer，2022，277：107949.
[16] Rothman L S，Gordon I E，Barbe A，et al. Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy & Radiative Transfer，2009，110：533.
|
| [1] |
WANG Yi-hong, ZHOU Bin*, ZHAO Rong, WANG Bu-bin. Calibration-Free Wavelength Modulation Spectroscopy for Gas Properties Measuring Basedon 2nd and 4th Harmonics[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2023, 43(02): 368-373. |
| [2] |
DU Bao-lu, LI Meng, GUO Jin-jia*, ZHANG Zhi-hao, YE Wang-quan, ZHENG Rong-er. The Experimental Research on In-Situ Detection for Dissolved CO2 in
Seawater Based on Tunable Diode Laser Absorption Spectroscopy[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2022, 42(04): 1264-1269. |
| [3] |
MA Li1, 2, FAN Xin-li1, 2, ZHANG Shuo1, 2, WANG Wei-feng1, 2, WEI Gao-ming1, 2. Research on CH4 Gas Detection and Temperature Correction Based on TDLAS Technology[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2021, 41(11): 3632-3638. |
| [4] |
WANG Guo-shui1, GUO Ao2, LIU Xiao-nan1, FENG Lei1, CHANG Peng-hao1, ZHANG Li-ming1, LIU Long1, YANG Xiao-tao1*. Simulation and Influencing Factors Analysis of Gas Detection System Based on TDLAS Technology[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2021, 41(10): 3262-3268. |
| [5] |
LU Yi-bing1, 2, LIU Wen-qing1, 2, ZHANG Yu-jun1, 2*, ZHANG Kai1, 2, HE Ying1, 2, YOU Kun1, 2, LI Xiao-yi1, LIU Guo-hua1, 2, TANG Qi-xing1, 2, FAN Bo-qiang1, 2, YU Dong-qi1, 2, LI Meng-qi1, 2. An Adaptive Hierarchical Savitzky-Golay Spectral Filtering Algorithm and Its Application[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2019, 39(09): 2657-2663. |
| [6] |
YANG Yan-fang1, 2, PEI Kai-long1, 2, YIN Xu-kun1, 2, WU Hong-peng1, 2, LI Shang-zhi1, 2, CUI Ru-yue1, 2, MA Wei-guang1, 2, ZHANG Lei1, 2, YIN Wang-bao1, 2, DONG Lei1, 2*, JIA Suo-tang1, 2. Photoacoustic Spectroscopy Based Methane Sensor Using a Double-Pass Photoacoustic Cell[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2018, 38(02): 616-620. |
| [7] |
ZHU Gao-feng1, 2, HU Xin1, ZHU Hong-qiu1*, HU En-ze1, ZHU Jian-ping3. The Multi-Beam Interference Suppression for Measuring Penicillin Vial’s Oxygen Concentration Based on Tunable Diode Laser Absorption Spectroscopy[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2018, 38(02): 372-376. |
| [8] |
LI Chuan-liang1*, JIANG Li-jun1, SHAO Li-gang1, GUO Xin-qian1, QIU Xuan-bing1, WEI Ji-lin1, GAO Rui1, WANG Gao2. The Detection of CO Based on TDLAS Combined with Balanced Difference Detection Technology[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2017, 37(10): 3165-3169. |
| [9] |
NIE Wei1, 2, YE Qing-hao3, XU Zhen-yu1, ZHANG Guang-le1, XIA Hui-hui1, 2, KAN Rui-feng1* . Study on the Method of Voigt Profiles Two Wings Fitting Non-Uniform Flow Field Absorbance [J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2017, 37(03): 816-821. |
| [10] |
LI Bin1, LIU Hui-fang1, HE Qi-xin1, ZHAI Bing1, PAN Jiao-qing2, ZHENG Chuan-tao1*, WANG Yi-ding1* . A Methane Detection System Using Distributed Feedback Laser at 1 654 nm[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2016, 36(01): 20-26. |
| [11] |
CHEN Jiu-ying1, LIU Jian-guo1*, HE Jun-feng2, HE Ya-bai1, ZHANG Guang-le1, XU Zhen-yu1, GANG Qiang3, WANG Liao3, YAO Lu1, YUAN Song1, RUAN Jun1, DAI Yun-hai1, KAN Rui-feng1 . Study of High Temperature Water Vapor Concentration Measurement Method Based on Absorption Spectroscopy [J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2014, 34(12): 3174-3177. |
| [12] |
SONG Jun-ling, HONG Yan-ji, WANG Guang-yu, PAN Hu . Measurement of Nonuniform Temperature and Concentration Distribution by Absorption Spectroscopy Based on Least-Square Fitting [J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2013, 33(08): 2047-2050. |
| [13] |
LOU Nan-zheng, LI Ning*, WENG Chun-sheng. In Situ Temperature Measurement by Absorption Spectroscopy Based on Time Division Multiplexing Technology[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2012, 32(05): 1329-1333. |
| [14] |
TIAN Yong-zhi1,2, LIU Jian-guo1*, ZHANG Yu-jun1, LU Yi-huai1, HE Ying1 . On Using Tunable Diode Laser Absorption Spectroscopy to Determine Gas Fluxes over Cropland [J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2012, 32(04): 1072-1076. |
| [15] |
GAO Wei1, 2, CAO Zhen-song1, 2, YUAN Yi-qian1, 2, GAO Xiao-ming1, 2* . Design of a Controllable Low Temperature Cell and Application[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2012, 32(03): 858-861. |
|
|
|
|
