A Study on Mineral Material Sources of Multi-Style Bronzes Collected by Cultural Relic Administration Center of Huili County, Sichuan Province With MC-ICP-MS
BI Yan-qi1, 2 , YANG Ying-dong3, DU Jing4, TANG Xiang5, LUO Wu-gan1, 2*
1. Key Laboratory of Vertebrate Evolution and Human Origins，Institute of Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology，Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100044，China
2. Department of Archaeology and Anthropology, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049，China
3. Center of Scientific Archaeology in Chengdu Archaeological Institute, Chengdu 610000，China
4. National Cultural Heritage Administration, Beijing 100009，China
5. Cultural Relic Administration Center of Huili County, Huili 615100, China
Abstract：The provenance of raw materials of bronzes and the cultural interactions between regions embodied in them are the key issues that archaeologists focus on. Huili County, Sichuan Province, is located at the “crossroads” between the Eurasian Steppes, the Central Plains of China, South Asia and Southeast Asia, and is on the famous “Tibet-Yi Corridor”. The bronzes unearthed from Huili also contains a variety of cultural factors. However, previous studies on bronze culture in this area have mostly focused on the cultural interactions embodied in the shape of tombs and the types and decorations of burial objects, with little discussion on the provenance of minerals of multi-style bronzes and the specific modes of cultural interaction between regions. In this work, 8 multi-style bronzes collected by the Cultural Relic Administration Center of Huili County were analyzed using a portable X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (pXRF), and multi-receiver inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (MC-ICP-MS). On this basis, the lead isotope data of copper and lead mines and related bronzes were collected and compared to archaeological typology to grasp the interaction between different regions and bronze cultures. The composition results obtained by pXRF show that these samples have various alloy types, including pure copper, tin bronze, lead-tin bronze and tin-lead bronze. The lead isotope ratios results obtained by MC-ICP-MS indicate that the two Shizhaishan style drums and Yanyuan culture style tree-shape bronzes should be importation which used the lead material from south central Yunnan province. The results of previous studies on several Shizhaishan style bronze drums show that the mineral materials are all from south central Yunnan, indicating that the raw mineral and production of bronze drums, which symbolize power and status, are relatively unique and may be monopolized by the ruling class. While the Shizhaishan style bell is, an imitation used the copper material from Huili County. The results indicate complex culture interaction modes, including spiritual level and material objects among Huili, Shizhaishan, Yanyuan and other surrounding bronze cultures. This study also shows that using pXRF and MC-ICP-MS to clarify the composition and the source of mineral materials of bronzes combined with documentary records and archaeological typology can provide positive evidence support for in-depth exploration of specific modes of cultural interactions between regions.
Key words：Bronzes;Multi-style;Mineral material sources;Culture interaction modes;MC-ICP-MS
毕研琦，杨颖东，杜 靖，唐 翔，罗武干. 四川会理文管所藏多元风格青铜器矿料来源的MC-ICP-MS分析[J]. 光谱学与光谱分析, 2023, 43(04): 1140-1146.
BI Yan-qi , YANG Ying-dong, DU Jing, TANG Xiang, LUO Wu-gan. A Study on Mineral Material Sources of Multi-Style Bronzes Collected by Cultural Relic Administration Center of Huili County, Sichuan Province With MC-ICP-MS. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2023, 43(04): 1140-1146.
[1] HUANG Yi-zhe（黄一哲）. Journal of National Museum of China(中国国家博物馆馆刊)，2020，(9): 6.
[2] ZHAO De-yun，CHEN Ya-jun, WANG Huai-rong, et al(赵德云，陈亚军，王槐荣，等). Archaeological Discoveries in Chengdu(成都考古发现)，2008，(0): 213.
[3] Liangshan Yi Autonomous Prefecture Museum，Chengdu Municipal Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology(凉山彝族自治州博物馆, 成都文物考古研究所). Laolongtou Cemetery and Bronze Artifacts Collected in Yanyuan(老龙头墓地与盐源青铜器). Beijing：Cultural Relics Press(北京：文物出版社)，2009. 152.
[4] BAO Yue-he(包月河). Sichuan Cultural Relics(四川文物), 1989, (5): 66.
[5] PENG Chang-lin(彭长林). Southern Ethnology and Archaeology(南方民族考古), 2016，(2): 185.
[6] TAO Ming-kuan(陶鸣宽). Archaeology(考古), 1982，(2): 216.
[7] ZHANG Xin-ning(张新宁). Archaeology(考古), 2001，(12): 25.
[8] Yunnan Provincial Museum(云南省博物馆). Excavation Report of Shizhaishan Ancient Tomb Group in Jinning, Yunnan(云南晋宁石寨山古墓群发掘报告). Beijing：Cultural Relics Press(北京：文物出版社)，1959. 81.
[9] Figueiredo E, Valério P, Araújo M F, et al. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2007, 580(1): 725.
[10] ZENG Pei-yan(曾培炎). Encyclopedia of Western China Development Information· Sichuan Volume(中国西部开发信息百科·四川卷). Chengdu：Sichuan Science & Technology Press(成都：四川科学技术出版社)，2003，（10）: 92.
[11] Chen D, Yang Y, Du J, et al. Heritage Science, 2020, 8(1): 69.
[12] CUI Jian-feng, WU Xiao-hong(崔剑锋, 吴小红). The Study of Lead Isotopic Archaeology(铅同位素考古研究). Beijing：Cultural Relics Press(北京：文物出版社), 2008. 105.
[13] ZHUANG Yong-qiu，WANG Ren-zhong, YANG Shu-pei, et al(庄永秋，王任重，杨树培，等). Gejiu Tin-copper Polymetallic Deposit, Yunnan(云南个旧锡铜多金属矿床). Beijing：Seismological Press(北京：地震出版社), 1996. 117.
[14] GAO Zi-ying(高子英). Yunnan Geology(云南地质), 1997, (4): 359.
[15] CUI Jian-feng, WU Xiao-hong(崔剑锋，吴小红). The Study of Lead Isotopic Archaeology(铅同位素考古研究). Beijing：Cultural Relics Press(北京：文物出版社), 2008. 73.
[16] TANG Xiang (唐翔). Sichuan Cultural Relics(四川文物), 1999，(4): 51.
[17] Liangshan Yi Autonomous Prefecture Museum，Chengdu Municipal Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology(凉山彝族自治州博物馆, 成都文物考古研究所). Laolongtou Cemetery and Bronze Artifacts Collected in Yanyuan(老龙头墓地与盐源青铜器). Beijing：Cultural Relics Press(北京：文物出版社)，2009. 212.
