Methods of Analyzing Soybean Meal Adulteration in Fish Meal Based on Visible and Near Infrared Reflectance Spectroscopy
SHI Guang-tao1,2,HAN Lu-jia1,2*,YANG Zeng-ling1,2，LIU Xian1,2
1. College of Engineering, China Agricultural University, Beijing 100083, China 2. Key Laboratory of Modern Precision Agriculture System Integration, Ministry of Education, Beijing 100083, China
Abstract：The present study investigated the feasibility of visible and near infrared reflectance spectroscopy (NIRS) method for the detection of fish meal adulteration with vegetable meal. Here the authors collected fish meal and soybean meal (representative vegetable meal) which were common used in our country. Fish meal was adulterated with different proportion of soybean meal and then the doping test samples were prepared. Qualitative discriminant analysis and quantitative analysis were studied with representative fish meal adulterated with soybean meal. Two hundred and six calibration samples and 103 validation samples were used in the qualitative discriminant analysis. The effects of different spectrum pre-treatment methods and spectrum regions were considered when the qualitative discriminant analysis model was established. Based on the smallest standard error of cross validation (SECV) and the correct rate, the spectrum region of visible and NIR was chosen as the best region. The eventually established pre-treatment methods were the standard multi-scatter correction (Std MSC) combined with the second derivative (2, 4, 4, 1). Then the independent external validation set was used to test the model, and there was no false positive samples and false negative samples. The correct discriminant rate was 96.12%. In quantitative analysis, 130 fish meal samples adulterated with soybean meal were used as calibration set. The calibration model was established by partial least squares (PLS). Furthermore, the effect of different spectrum pre-treatment methods and the spectrum region were considered. The results showed that the best pre-treatment method was the standard normalized variate (SNV) combined with the second derivative (2, 4, 4, 1). The coefficient of determination (R2) and the standard errors of calibration (SEC) were 0.989 0 and 1.539 0 respectively between the predictive value and the actual value. Sixty five fish meal samples adulterated with soybean meal were used as independent validation set. The coefficient of determination (R2) and the standard errors of prediction (SEP) were 0.988 8 and 1.786 0 respectively, and the ratio of standard deviation of reference data in prediction sample set to the standard errors of prediction (RPD) was 8.61. The results showed that the NIRS could be used as a method to detect the existence and the content of soybean meal in fish meal.
石光涛1,2,韩鲁佳1,2*,杨增玲1,2,刘贤1,2 . 鱼粉中掺杂豆粕的可见和近红外反射光谱分析研究[J]. 光谱学与光谱分析, 2009, 29(02): 362-366.
SHI Guang-tao1,2,HAN Lu-jia1,2*,YANG Zeng-ling1,2，LIU Xian1,2. Methods of Analyzing Soybean Meal Adulteration in Fish Meal Based on Visible and Near Infrared Reflectance Spectroscopy. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2009, 29(02): 362-366.
[1] LU Wan-zhen，YUAN Hong-fu，XU Guang-tong，et al(陆婉珍，袁洪福，徐广通，等). The Modern Analysis Technique for Near-Infrared Spectra(现代近红外光谱分析技术). Beijing：Chinese Oil and Chemical Press(北京：中国石油化工出版社)，2001. 1. [2] SUN Jian-ying，LI Min-zan，ZHENG Li-hua，et al(孙建英，李民赞，郑立华，等). Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis(光谱学与光谱分析)，2006，26(3)：426. [3] JIANG Huan-yu，YING Yi-bin(蒋焕煜，应义斌). Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis(光谱学与光谱分析)，2007，27(3)：499. [4] Jocelyne A，Dominique G. Animal Feed Science and Technology. 1996，62(3)：77. [5] Dolores C，Garrido-Varo A，Guerrero J E. Animal Feed Science and Technology. 2004，116(3，4)：333. [6] Institute of Animal Sciences，Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences(中国农业科学院畜牧研究所编). Near Infrared Reflectance Spectroscopy Analysis Technology(近红外光谱分析技术). Beijing：China Agriculture Press(北京：中国农业出版社)，1993. 23. [7] LIU Xian，HAN Lu-jia(刘 贤，韩鲁佳). Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis(光谱学与光谱分析)，2006，26(11)：2016. [8] NIU Zhi-you，HAN Lu-jia，SU Xiao-ou，et al (牛智有，韩鲁佳，苏晓鸥，等). Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery(农业机械学报)，2006，37(8)：126. [9] CAI Bin，LIU Ben-dong，XIAO Yu-ping(蔡 斌，刘本栋，肖玉平). Veterinary Pharmaceuticals and Feed Additives(兽药与饲料添加剂)，1999，4(6)：30. [10] XUE Chun-lin，SUN Da-ming(薛春林，孙大明). China Feed(中国饲料)，1995，(19)：31. [11] WANG Xiao-ling，LIU Xue-mei(王晓玲，刘雪梅). China Feed(中国饲料)，1999，(10)：22. [12] Fish Meal Standard(鱼粉标准). GB/T 19164—2003. [13] WU Jian-guo，SHI Chun-hai，ZHANG Hai-zhen(吴建国，石春海，张海珍). Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis(光谱学与光谱分析)，2006，26(2)：259. [14] Xiccato G，Trocino A, Boever J. Animal Feed Science and Technology, 2003, 104(4)：153. [15] Park R S，Agnew R E，Gordon F J，et al. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol.，1998，72：155. [16] Williams P C. Journal of Near Infrared Spectroscopy，1993，1：25. [17] Malley D F，Findlay D L，Zippel B. Journal of Paleolimnolopy，1999，21(3)：295. [18] YAN Yan-lu，ZHAO Long-lian，HAN Dong-hai，et al(严衍禄，赵龙莲，韩东海，等). Near Infrared Spectroscopy Basis and Application(近红外光谱分析基础与应用). Beijing：China Light Industry Press(北京：中国轻工业出版社)，2005. 1.
