光谱学与光谱分析 |
|
|
|
|
|
Evaluation on the Atmospheric Correction Methods for Water Color Remote Sensing by Using HJ-1A/1B CCD Image-Taking Poyang Lake in China as a Case |
ZENG Qun1,2, ZHAO Yue2, TIAN Li-qiao3*, CHEN Xiao-ling3, 4 |
1. Editorial Department of Journal, Central China Normal University, Wuhan 430079, China 2. School of Urban and Environment Science, Central China Normal University, Wuhan 430079, China 3. State Key Laboratory of Information Engineering in Surveying, Mapping and Remote Sensing, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430079,China 4. The Key Laboratory of Poyang Lake Wetland and Watershed Research, Ministry of Education, Jiangxi Normal University, Nanchang 330022,China |
|
|
Abstract HJ-1A/1B satellite CCD images have higher spatial and temporal resolution, making them of great potential in quantitatively monitoring the water quality of inland lakes. However, the atmospheric correction of the images restricts their application. Therefore, taking Poyang Lake, the biggest freshwater lake in China as study area , and using the in-situ data collected in 2009 and 2011, this paper compares the atmospheric correction results done by the four methods: FLAASH, 6S, COST and QUAC, and analyzes the influence of these atmospheric correction methods on the inversion accuracy of the total suspended sediments (TSS) concentration. The results indicate: (1) the band 1 (blue band) of HJ-1A/1B CCD satellite images should be recalibrated while being applied into water quality remote sensing. The accuracy of atmospheric correction done from band 2 (green band) and band 3 (red band) is higher than that of others , especially that of the correction done by FLAASH, 6S and COST is much higher while that of correction done by QUAC is lower. So the algorithms of QUAC should be pointedly improved. (2) The ratios done from band 2 and band 3 have a good match with in-situ data , with an average relative error of 8.2%, 9.5%, 7.6% and 11.6% respectively for FLAASH, 6S, COST and QUAC. Therefore, it would be better to use the ratio done from band 2 and band 3 as inversion factors in Poyang Lake. (3) It is found that the accuracy of directly building models by using the four atmospheric corrected results and the TSS concentration is higher than the models built by the in-situ remote sensing reflectance and the TSS concentration. The accuracy of the TSS concentration inverted by FLAASH, 6S and COST is much high with an average error of only 10.0%, 10.2% and 8.0% respectively, while the error inverted by QUAC is a little bit higher of being 18.6%. So it is suggested to build model with atmospheric correction results and the TSS concentration data, because it can avoid the cumulate error resulted from modeling by using the in-situ spectrum data. (4) Under a low requested situation, these four atmospheric correction algorithms can all be adopted; otherwise, the COST should be used in the case of lacking supplementary information.
|
Received: 2013-01-09
Accepted: 2013-03-09
|
|
Corresponding Authors:
TIAN Li-qiao
E-mail: tianliqiao@whu.edu.cn;tianye2003@gmail.com
|
|
[1] Gordon H R, Wang M H. Applied Optics,1994,33: 443. [2] PAN De-lu, Doerffer R(潘德炉,Doerffer R). Acta Oceanologica Sinica(海洋学报),1997,19: 43. [3] YU Zhifeng, CHEN Xiaoling, ZHOU Bin, et al. Chinese Journal of Oceanology and Limnology,2012,30(2): 295. [4] JIN Xin, LI Yun-mei, WANG Qiao, et al(金 鑫,李云梅,王 桥,等). Journal of Lake Sciences(湖泊科学),2010,22(4): 504. [5] XU Hua, GU Xing-fa, LI Zheng-qiang, et al(许 华,顾行发,李正强,等). Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis (光谱学与光谱分析),2011,31(10):2798. [6] TIAN Liqiao, LU Jianzhong, CHEN Xiaoling, et al. Science China: Technological Sciences,2010,53: 191. [7] YU Xiujuan, YAN Qin, LIU Zhengjun. The 3rd International Congress on Image and Signal Processing, Yantai, China. 2010,5: 2125. [8] DU Xin, CHEN Xue-yang, MENG Ji-hua, et al(杜 鑫,陈雪洋,蒙继华,等). Remote Sensing for Land & Resources(国土资源遥感),2010,2: 22. [9] SUN Zhiqun, LIU Zhihui. Proceedings of 2010 International Conference on Remote Sensing, Hangzhou, China. 2010. 3. [10] WANG Menghua, Shi W. Optics Express, 2007,15(24): 15722. [11] FENG Lian, HU Chuanmin, CHEN Xiaoling, et al. Human Induced Turbidity Changes in Poyang Lake between 2000 and 2010: Observations from MODIS. Journal of Geophysical. Research – Oceans. 117, C07006. [12] HU Chuanmin, CHEN Zhiqiang, CLAYTON Tonya D,et al. Remote Sensing of Environment,2004,90(3): 423. [13] ITT Visual Information Solutions. Atmospheric Correction Module: QUAC and FLAASH User’s Guide,2009. [14] CUI Lijuan, WU Guofeng, Liu Yaoling. Hydrological Processes,2009,23: 342. [15] TANG Jun-wu, TIAN Guo-liang, WANG Xiao-yong, et al(唐军武, 田国良, 王小勇,等). Journal of Remote Sensing(遥感学报),2004,8(1): 37. [16] Vermote E, Tanre D, Deuze J L, et al. 6S User Guide Version 2. 1997. 7. [17] ZHAO Yue, ZENG Qun, CHEN Xiao-ling, et al(赵 越,曾 群,陈晓玲,等). Journal of Huazhong Normal University(华中师范大学学报),2012,46(6): 757. [18] HUANG Miao-fen, NIU Sheng-li, SUN Zhong-ping, et al(黄妙芬,牛生丽,孙中平,等). Remote Sensing Information(遥感信息),2010,4: 68.
|
[1] |
YANG Jun-jie1, HUANG Miao-fen2*, LUO Wei-jian3, WANG Zhong-lin2, XING Xu-feng2. The Effect of Oil-in-Water on the Upward Radiance Spectrum in Seawater[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2022, 42(05): 1648-1653. |
[2] |
LIU Xiao-yan, YANG Qian*, LIU Qiao-jun. Adaptability Analysis of Various Versions of GDPS Based on QA Score for GOCI Data Processing in the Yellow Sea[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2021, 41(07): 2233-2239. |
[3] |
LIU Xiao-yan1, YANG Qian1*, CHEN Shu-guo2, HU Lian-bo2, ZONG Fang-yi1, LIU Qiao-jun1. The Scattering Characteristics and Classifications of Particulate Matters in Jiaozhou Bay and Qingdao Coastal Areas[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2020, 40(10): 3102-3107. |
[4] |
TIAN Li-qiao1, LI Sen1*, SUN Xiang-han1, TONG Ru-qing1, SONG Qing-jun2, SUN Zhao-hua3, LI Yong1. Development of a Novel Floating Water Spectral Measurement System Based on Skylight-Blocked Approach[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2020, 40(09): 2756-2763. |
[5] |
PANG Shu-na1, ZHU Wei-ning1*, CHEN Jiang2, SUN Nan3, HUANG Li-tong1, ZHANG Yu-sen1, ZHANG Ze-liang1. Using Landsat-8 to Remotely Estimate and Observe Spatio-Temporal Variations of Total Suspended Matter in Zhoushan Coastal Regions[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2019, 39(12): 3826-3832. |
[6] |
YE Fa-wang, WANG Jian-gang*, QIU Jun-ting, ZHANG Chuan. A Geological Application Oriented Comparison Research on Different Atmospheric Correction Methods for Airborne CASI-SASI Hyperspectral Data[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2019, 39(09): 2677-2685. |
[7] |
ZHAO Xin1, XU Zhan-jun1*, YIN Jian-ping2, BI Ru-tian1, FENG Jun-fang1, LIU Pei3. Retrieval of Soil Organic Carbon in Cinnamon Mining Belt Subsidence Area Based on OLI and 6SV[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2019, 39(03): 886-893. |
[8] |
SONG Ting1, 2, GONG Shao-qi3, LIU Jun-zhi4, 5*, GU Zheng-fan2, SHI Jun-zhe2, WU Wei2. Performance Assessment of Atmospheric Correction for Multispectral Data of GF-4 on Inland Case Ⅱ Turbid Water[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2018, 38(04): 1191-1197. |
[9] |
PAN Cen-cen1, YAN Qing-wu1, DING Jian-wei2, ZHANG Qian-qian1, TAN Kun1*. Atmospheric Correction of Airborne Hyperspectral Image Based on Fruit Fly-Powell Optimization Algorithm[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2018, 38(01): 224-234. |
[10] |
XU Kai-jian1, 2, ZENG Hong-da3, 4, ZHU Xiao-bo1, 2, TIAN Qing-jiu1*. Evaluation of Five Commonly Used Atmospheric Correction Algorithms for Multi-Temporal Aboveground Forest Carbon Storage Estimation[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2017, 37(11): 3493-3498. |
[11] |
SHEN Qian, LI Jun-sheng*, ZHANG Bing, WU Yan-hong, ZOU Lei, WU Tai-xia . Analyzing Spectral Characteristics of Water Involving In-Situ Multiangle Polarized Reflectance and Extraction of Water-Leaving Radiance [J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2016, 36(10): 3269-3273. |
[12] |
XIE Dong-hai1, 3, CHEN Tian-hai2*, WU Yu2, YU Jie1, 3, GUO Hong2, ZHONG Ruo-fei1, 3. Atmospheric Correction for HJ-1 CCD Data Coupling with Aerosol Models of Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Region[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2016, 36(05): 1284-1290. |
[13] |
QIU Yu-bao1, SHI Li-juan2, 4, SHI Jian-cheng2, ZHAO Shao-jie3 . Atmospheric Influences Analysis on the Satellite Passive Microwave Remote Sensing[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2016, 36(02): 310-315. |
[14] |
LIU Jia1,2, GONG Fang1*, HE Xian-qiang1, ZHU Qian-kun1, HUANG Hai-qing1 . Impact of Light Polarization on the Measurement of Water Particulate Backscattering Coefficient [J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2016, 36(01): 31-37. |
[15] |
DAI Qian1,2, PAN De-lu1, HE Xian-qiang1*, ZHU Qian-kun1, GONG Fang1, HUANG Hai-qing1. High-Frequency Observation of Water Spectrum and Its Application in Monitoring of Dynamic Variation of Suspended Materials in the Hangzhou Bay[J]. SPECTROSCOPY AND SPECTRAL ANALYSIS, 2015, 35(11): 3247-3254. |
|
|
|
|